Lightly adapted from Smitten Kitchen’s Everyday Meatballs, which are fabulous
I did not (re)name these meatballs based on the meat content. They’re 1/2 and 1/2 because you’re going to freeze half of them. At least half. Freeze more if you don’t want meatballs for more than one meal in a row, or if bringing meatballs for lunch sounds like The Worst. (But also, why? Who are you?)
These freeze goshdamn beautifully, and frozen meatballs are clutch for days when you’re too lazy to order delivery, too tired to do much work and don’t want to think too hard about dinner. Which, honestly, is frequently over here.
So make a big-ass batch now, and your future self will thank you.
Recipe yield: About 48 meatballs (about 2 Tablespoons each. I used a 2 Tbsp. cookie scoop)
Which is…we’re going to say six servings, because eight meatballs sounds like a reasonable serving size, right? And 48 meatballs divided by 8 meatballs = 6 servings of meatballs heck yes I passed math.
What You Need for the Meatballs:
1 pound ground turkey
1 pound ground pork/beef/lamb/chicken–take your pick, they all work well. Really love turkey? Do another pound of turkey.
3/4 cup panko bread crumbs
2/3 cup water
4 eggs
1/4 cup chopped parsley
1 1/2 teaspoon onion powder
2 teaspoons salt
1 teaspoon ground pepper or crushed red pepper flakes
3 garlic cloves, minced (fresh or use jarred)
What You Need for the Sauce: For the meatballs you’re eating tonight.
You’ll need to remake this (or use a good jarred sauce) for future preparation of the meatballs.
2 Tablespoons olive oil
2 garlic cloves, minced
Small pinch of red pepper flakes, if you want some heat.
1 28-oz can of crushed San Marzano tomatoes, no salt added. (Do they neeeeeeed to be San Marzano tomatoes? Yes. Your meatballs will not cook in regular tomatoes and you’ll have raw meatballs. Is this a lie? Yes.)
What You Need to Do: Meatballs
Get out your largest bowl.
Line 2 baking sheets with waxed paper or parchment paper.
Mix the meat, panko, water, eggs, parsley, onion powder, salt, pepper/red pepper flakes and 3 minced garlic cloves together in the large bowl. All the meat ingredients. Mash ’em up. Use your hands, use a fork, use a spoon, use a spatula, use your toothbrush, I don’t care. Just mix them up, but don’t go completely HAM on them. Once they look reasonably mixed up, move on.
Take a 2-Tbsp cookie scoop (or use a measuring spoon, or eyeball it) and scoop out your meatballs. Line ’em up on the baking sheets.
Stick one baking sheet full of meatballs in the freezer.
Stick the other baking sheet full of meatballs in the fridge.
WAIT LIKE 20 MINUTES AND THEN START THE SAUCE (but leave the meatballs in the fridge. They like it there.)
What You Need to Do: Sauce
Put on an apron or a black shirt. Don’t wear light colors for this. Just trust me.
Heat the 2 Tbsp olive oil in a pot over medium heat. (This is similar to what I use.)
Add the red pepper flakes if you’re using them.
Wait 10-15 seconds and then…
Add the garlic.
Wait 30ish seconds and then…
Add the tomatoes. BEWARE THE SPLASHY SPLASHING OF TOMATOES
Reduce your heat to low and let it simmer for about 5 minutes. Add a pinch of salt (or don’t, if you didn’t use unsalted tomatoes). That’s all you need.
What You Need to Do: Combine the two.
Pull your meatballs from the fridge and drop them (gently) in the sauce.
The sauce doesn’t need to fully cover the meatballs. They’ll be fine.
Put the lid on your sauce, double check the heat is on low and walk away for 10 minutes. Do not touch them. You can peek at them, but keep it to a minimum. They will need a total of 25 minutes of cooking time. But walk away for 10 and then…start pasta or whatever. Do the dishes. Write a poem.
I usually make about 16 meatballs at a time (because 8 meatballs = serving size and also that is what fit comfortably in my pot which is very convenient.)
After 10 minutes, start your pasta (I like Banza or POW for extra protein, fewer carbs, which is also maybe my way of saying I quit buying regular pasta after I realized it is CRIMINALLY easy to make homemade pasta and Italy has been running a masterful scam for centuries) or toast up some bread–I have eaten these on top of veggies instead of pasta and used bread to get the last of the sauce, and I’ve eaten these plain in a bowl because meatballs are delicious. Choose your own adventure.
After 25 minutes, your meatballs will be done. Nervous? Fish one out with a spoon, cut it in half and look for pink-ness. Not pink? It’s done.
Set them aside so you’re not serving yourself a bowl of boiling tomatoes and finish up your pasta/bread/veggies. Then combine THOSE and, congratulations, you’ve made dinner.
What You Need to Do: Frozen meatballs oh god you have meatballs in the freezer
Let them freeze on the baking sheet. When they’re fully frozen (so, like, an hourish?), pluck them off the sheet into a giant plastic bag or freezer-safe container.
To make the meatballs from the freezer, just heat up the sauce to simmering (recipe above, a jar of sauce, etc.) and plunk the frozen meatballs right in and turn the heat to low. They only take a few extra minutes to cook. Check one after 30. If it’s not cooked, try 35. It’s easy.
How Long is This Going to Take Me?
From opening the fridge to cleaning up dishes after eating the meatballs, this took me 90 minutes, and like…eating time is included in there. Actual work time? An hour. And even THAT includes 20 minutes of leaving the meatballs alone in the fridge while you write sonnets.
Is this even healthy?
8 meatballs have, according to MyFitnessPal’s recipe calculator, 400 calories. (Calculated using turkey/pork combo, so if you change the meat, you’ll change the calories. All turkey will be fewer calories.) If you eat this with one serving of regular pasta, add on another 200 calories. 600 isn’t bad for dinner, but also eat a salad. Also also, I’m including the calories as a very general measure. I don’t think all calories are equal (because they aren’t) but if you’re looking for a way to gauge, I think it’s an easy shorthand.
What if I mess it up?
If your meatballs fall apart in the sauce, crush them up further and congratulations you’ve made pasta sauce. If you burn the garlic, clean out the pan, take a deep breath and start that part over. If you drop your bowl on the floor, you have meatballs in the freezer!